For thousands of years, humans have relied on food preservation techniques like pickling and salting to extend the shelf life of ingredients and avoid spoilage. But while both methods inhibit microbial growth through the use of acid, salt, or controlled fermentation, the specific processes involved can be quite different. Understanding these key distinctions is critical for achieving the desired effects on safety, texture, and flavor in any preserved food. Whether making sauerkraut at home or manufacturing pickled peppers on an industrial scale, it pays to learn the nuances of brining versus lacto-fermenting versus jarring. This article will navigate the complex world of preservation to highlight what sets pickling and salting apart.

Pickling Basics

What is Pickling?

Pickling refers to preserving fruits, vegetables, proteins, and more in an acidic liquid brine. While versions of pickling have existed for over 4,000 years, the term comes from the Dutch “pekel,” meaning brine. Most picklings aim to extend freshness and inhibit spoilage while imparting a pleasantly sour, salty flavor. Common pickled foods across cultures include cucumbers, cabbages for sauerkraut, onions, eggs, pig’s feet, and even fruits like lemons and watermelon rind. The signature tang comes from the pickling process itself.

The Pickling Process

The pickling process relies on immersing raw ingredients in a brine with a pH below 4.6, creating an environment that is too acidic for bacterial growth. The brine usually contains salt, vinegar, and/or lactic acid from natural fermentation. This acidity denatures proteins on the food’s surface, while the salt can penetrate deeper to draw out moisture. The result? A crisp-tender texture and balanced flavor profile. The duration of the brine solution can range from a few minutes for quick refrigerator pickles to over a year for fully-cured olives.

Types of Pickling

Many types of pickling exist, with differences in techniques used, ingredients added, and preservation time. Quick or refrigerator pickles take minutes to days by briefly marinating chopped foods like onions, eggs, and cucumbers in vinegar-based brines. No heat processing involved—just tasty convenience! Sauerkraut, kimchi, and other fermented pickles rely instead on salted cabbage left to naturally lactoferment with beneficial bacteria for weeks, developing unique sour and umami depth. Coppa di Parma progresses for over a year, emerging as complex, tender cured meat. Finally, canned or jarred pickles undergo full heat processing for long-term, unrefrigerated storage, as in classic dill spears.

Comparing Processes

Key Differences

While pickling and salting both inhibit microbial growth to extend shelf life, several key differences exist between these ancient arts. Pickling relies on immersion in an acid brine with a pH below 4.6 created by added vinegar, lactic acid from fermentation, or both. This acidity rapidly denatures surface proteins in food. Salting instead controls water activity, using dry salt or wet brines to trigger the osmosis of moisture out of food tissues.

Additionally, live fermentation with beneficial bacteria is central to many pickled products like kimchi and sauerkraut, developing complex flavors and continuing acidification over weeks or months. Salting does not use fermentation.

In terms of food safety, both salting’s dehydration and pickling’s acidity effectively prohibit dangerous pathogen growth when properly executed. For preservation, products pickled with added vinegar last for months refrigerated or years canned, while fermented items stay safe as long as the pH remains below 4.6. Salted meats like prosciutto and salted fish can endure unrefrigerated for years once adequately desiccated.

Finally, pickling’s acid and ferment flavors lend tang, spice, and rich umami to balance the salt, while salting concentrates natural meaty, earthy tastes. Both processes will firm certain textures—pickling by denaturing surface proteins and salting through osmotic dehydration. The duration of each process interplays with the food’s initial structure to deliver anything from a tender brisket to crispy kimchi to unctuous fish sauce.

When to Choose Pickling vs. Salting

For quick flavor infusion, I prefer pickling, while salting requires days. Vinegar-jarred pickled peppers offer a vibrant kick in hours, unlike prosciutto’s year-long mellowing. Vegetables with low natural acidity also suit pickling better.

Salting shines when aiming for concentrated savor and complexity in meats and fish, especially smaller whole ones needing full penetration. Gravlax salmon develops more nuance than acid-pickled salmon. Salting also better preserves oils and fats compared to acidic pickling. And when the goal is crispy krauts or half-sours rather than a vinegar spear, ferment your pickles!

Combining Methods

While salting and pickling generally play distinct roles, many products integrate aspects of both. Lightly salted chunky vegetables may be pickled in vinegar, benefiting from the mild desiccation that vinegar alone cannot achieve. Pastrami relies first on salt-based meat curing before simmering in vinegar, garlic, and spices, doubling up on preservation and flavor. Even sauerkraut begins with dry-salting chopped cabbage to draw out juices for fermentation. And gravlax combines salted raw salmon with sugar and dill, borrowed from pickling spice blends. The lines between processes blur further in kimchi recipes with added shrimp or oysters. Multiple preservation pathways unite to keep foods safe and delicious.

While salting and pickling share similar preservation aims, the processes differ significantly. Pickling utilizes acidity for rapid flavor infusion, while salting gradually concentrates savor through osmotic dehydration. Both can have firm textures, but through distinct mechanisms. As tastes globalize, innovations continue to fuse elements of both arts while pushing boundaries with new ingredient combinations. In the hands of creative cooks and producers, traditional methods are melding in novel directions.

Categorized in: