When wandering through the produce aisle or perusing your vegetable garden, you may notice several varieties of cucumbers available. From short and plump Kirby cucumbers to long, slender English types, selecting the right cuke can make all the difference for your intended use. Two of the most common kinds are pickled cucumbers and the aptly named salad variety. Although they belong to the same plant species, key differences in size, texture, bitterness, and seed content mean that some types are better suited for eating fresh or pickling into brined treats. This article will compare the characteristics between pickling and salad cucumbers to help you determine which is best for your next recipe.

Pickling Cucumber Characteristics

Size & Shape

When it comes to pickling cucumbers, size and shape are two of the most important factors. Pickling varieties tend to be much smaller and shorter than standard salad cucumbers. On average, they grow to about 4–7 inches in length, which allows them to fit neatly into jars and barrels for the brining process.

Popular pickling cucumber varieties like National Pickling and Calypso produce blocky, chunky cukes that maintain a thick, stocky shape. This allows for a crispy, firm texture once pickled instead of waterlogged slices. Other types, like the Marketmore 76 hybrid, have been specially cultivated for profuse yields of smaller picklers perfect for bread and butter or dill recipes. No matter the exact variety, compact size and length are hallmarks of cucumbers destined for briny greatness.

Skin Texture

In addition to smaller dimensions, pickling cucumber skin differs notably from salad varieties. Pickling cukes require thicker, bumpier exterior peel that helps retain crispiness and crunch once pickled. The skin contains pektin and other compounds that prevent it from becoming soggy during processing.

Smooth-skinned varieties like Kirby or English salad cucumbers would fall apart after prolonged exposure to salty pickling liquid and vinegar. So prolific picklers opt for breeds like the aptly named Pick a Bushel hybrid that produces prolific volumes of stout picklers with rough, hardy green skin.

Seed Content & Bitterness

Because they are often preserved whole in jars instead of sliced or peeled, seed content plays a bigger role in the ideal pickling cucumber profile. Lower-moisture seeded varieties mean better-keeping quality once canned or brined. The inside flesh is also bred to eliminate bitterness to balance the sharp acidity of pickling brine or vinegar. Cooler growing conditions promote a higher sugar content for better flavor in the final pickled products.

Comparing Key Attributes

Size & Length

When placed side by side, the size and length differences between pickling and salad cucumbers become readily apparent. Pickling varieties max out at around 4–7 inches on average. Their stunted length and plump dimensions evolved for packing whole into jars and fermentation vessels. Salad cucumbers present the opposite aesthetic, thriving in long, slender proportions. Unencumbered by brining or closed quarters, salad cukes stretch their potential to 8 inches on the diminutive end and over a foot long among English greenhouse varieties.

These distinctive dimensions dictate their best uses. Short, chunky pickling cucumbers lend themselves obviously to pickled preparations or mixes of onion and vinegar. Their smaller size allows for quick penetration of liquids and spices. The elongated angles of salad cucumbers make them ideal for adding raw snap to sandwiches and using their length to garnish plates or wrap in rolls of fresh vegetables and greens.

Skin Thickness

In addition to divergent sizes, skin thickness represents perhaps the starkest contrast between pickling and salad-type cucumbers. Picklers develop rough, rigid exterior skin fortified to withstand the onion, garlic, and brine-packed conditions of preserved pickles. Bumpy skins give way to an ultra-crispy, satisfying texture and an appropriate resistance to becoming soggy over time immersed in liquid.

Salad cousins opt for the opposite approach: thin, delicate exteriors that don’t overpower fresh applications. Smooth, unassuming skins add a refreshing quality when consumed raw. They also require little to no peeling or prep work before slicing or serving straight out of the garden. These thin skins uniquely suit salad’s intended purpose without compromising on flavor or protean utility.

Seeds & Bitterness

The final distinctive quality between pickling and salad cucumbers comes down to the inner flesh and seed content. Picklers tolerate increased moisture and seed levels since they will ultimately be soaked and infused with salty, acidic ingredients during preservation. Without bitterness or hollow cores, knobby pickling cucumbers retain satisfying density and fiber no matter the application.

Salad varieties conversely fine-tune moisture content to crispy, water-rich flesh with diminished seeds. Too much moisture risks waterlogging, while pronounced seeds can overwhelm fresh applications. Expert breeding minimizes bitterness by manipulating growing times and conditions. The result: salad cucumbers ready to consume raw or complement recipes straight from harvest with cool, collected flavor built to combat unwanted astringency or off tastes.

Best Uses

Pickling Cucumbers

Given their name and culinary pedigree, the best and most traditional use for pickling cucumbers involves just that—pickling! Their smaller size, bumpy exterior, and firm, crisp flesh lend themselves perfectly to brining, fermenting, and preservation in salty vinegar or lactic acid-rich liquid. Iconic dishes like briny dill spears, sweet bread and butter chips, and the delectable sour mustard kraut relish all originate from the humble, hardy pickling cuke.

Beyond stereotypical pickle jars, stout pickling cucumbers also shine when cubed and added to salads for a juxtaposition of flavors and textures. Their inherent crunch stands up to assertive ingredients and dressings. Simply slicing fresh pickles and eating them with dips also captures their essence. Just take care not to overpower their subtle flavor in any raw preparation.

Salad Cucumbers

If pickling cucumbers occupy just one corner of the culinary spectrum, salad varieties flourish across a multitude of applications. True to their name, thinly slicing or spiral cutting salad cucumber varieties adds vibrant crunch and an eye-catching garnish to an infinite array of salads or lettuce-based dishes. Their mild flavor plays well with other fruits and veggies without being overpowering.

Salad cukes also serve as the perfect vehicle for sandwich fillings like tuna or egg salad, adding much-needed moisture and plant-based nutrients to lunchtime favorites. Simple munching also benefits from their cool, crisp, seedy crunch—no wonder the moniker snacking cucumber persists as well. For an unexpected twist, grilling or roasting elongated salad cucumbers brings out delicious new dimensions to their flavor; just be sure to brush with oil first to avoid drying out from the heat.

Tips for Substituting

While typically relegated to different roles based on texture, size, and intended use, sometimes substituting salad cucumbers for pickling or vice versa makes sense in a pinch. When needing to swap out varieties, keep these key considerations in mind:

Pickling salad cucumbers requires more prep work compared to standard bumpy picklers. Be sure to peel and cut out any large seeds before brining or jar-packing slender salad cukes. Add pickle crisping agents like grape leaves or oak to help retain texture amidst acidic ingredients. Refrigerator or quick pickling methods work better than prolonged fermenting when using salad types.

Conversely, while stout pickling cucumbers technically can be eaten raw, their thicker skin and more prominent seeds don’t make them ideal for salads. Peel the skin and scoop out the pulp and seeds first. Also, cut any remaining bitterness by salting sliced pickles beforehand to draw out excess moisture. Rinsing afterwards improves fresh flavor. Include plenty of other ingredients in raw preparations to help mellow rough edges.

When deciding which cucumbers to cultivate or select from the store, consider what you plan to ultimately use them for in the kitchen. Pickling varieties offer firm, compact sizes and bumpy skin, perfect for up to crispy pickled preparations. Slender salad types flourish with thin skins and mellow bitterness, making them ideal for consuming fresh or incorporating raw. While substituting works in a pinch, choosing varieties aligned with your culinary goals gives the best results for optimal texture, flavor, and enjoyment.

Categorized in: