Cucumbers are one of the most versatile vegetables around. These refreshing, low-calorie greens can be enjoyed raw in salads and sides or pickled and preserved into tasty condiments. Though they may look similar on the outside, there are actually two main varieties of cucumbers: slicers and picklers. Slicer cucumbers are cultivated to be eaten fresh, with thin skins and crisp, watery flesh. Pickling cucumbers are grown specifically for preservation, with bumpy skins and dense seeds that bring big flavor when soaked in brine. So what exactly makes these cucumber cousins so different? Read on to learn more about the distinguishing size, taste, texture, and best uses of slicers versus picklers. Identifying the right cuke for the job can make all the difference in your next recipe.

Slicer Cucumbers

Physical Characteristics

Slicer cucumbers are long, smooth-skinned varieties that make picture-perfect raw veggie platters. On average, slicers grow 8 to 10 inches in length with diameters between 2 and 3 inches. They have straight sides with blunt or rounded ends, yielding that iconic long tubular shape. The dark green skin is thin yet sturdy enough for slicing, usually with small white spines scattered across the ridges. Slicer cucumbers also contain very small, soft seeds that do not overpower the delicate, crunchy flesh.

Taste and Texture

When eaten fresh and raw, slicer cucumbers offer a delightfully crisp, juicy crunch. The water content is typically over 95%, making their moist flesh cool and refreshing. The thin skin does not require peeling, allowing the entire vegetable’s subtle sweetness and mild grassy flavors to shine through. The small, edible seeds provide just a hint of bitterness. The texture is very crispy and crunchy when sliced or snacked on whole.

Best Uses

With their mild taste, satisfying crunch, and pretty green color, slicer cucumbers are perfect for eating raw in salads, sides, snacks, and other chilled dishes. Their moisture makes them an ideal base for cold summer soups like gazpacho. Slicers also hold up well when cut or cubed for crunchy crudité platters with dips. The thin skin allows them to be served without peeling in sandwiches, wraps, tacos, and grain bowls too. Their classic oblong shape even makes them perfect pickle spear candidates.

Pickling Cucumbers

Physical Characteristics

Compared to slicers, pickling cucumbers are generally much smaller, bumpier, and more oval-shaped. They typically grow 3 to 5 inches long with diameters between 1 and 2 inches across. Instead of smooth sides, picklers often have irregular, knobby skin with visible spikes. The skin itself tends to be thicker as well. Inside, they contain abundant white seeds surrounded by flesh that is denser than slicers.

Taste and Texture

While slicers aim to be mild, crispy, and refreshing when eaten raw, picklers are cultivated for a whole different eating experience—fermentation! When soaked in salty vinegars, the bumpy pickling cucumber skin and plentiful seeds bring pronounced flavors, aromas, and snaps. The brining process transforms the otherwise bland and overly-seedy raw vegetable into a pungent, sour, and satisfying pickle bursting with spices, garlic, dill, and other intense tastes. The extra-thick skin helps the chunks maintain that signature crunch even when jarred or canned.

Best Uses

As their name implies, pickling cucumbers are intended for preservation into delicious pickled products like dill spears, bread & butter chips, relishes, and more. Their petite size fits neatly into jars, allowing home cooks and commercial processors to transform bumper crops into shelf-stable snacks and condiments that can be enjoyed year-round. Besides pickling whole, the chopped flesh is often used in prepared foods like condiments, salad dressings, soups, and pre-made side dishes too.

Key Differences

Size and Shape

The most obvious distinction between slicers and picklers is visible as soon as you see them. Slicers are generally much longer and thinner than picklers. On average, slicer varieties reach 8 to 10 inches in length, compared to just 3 to 5 inches for pickling types. Slicers also have skinnier diameters, usually between 2 and 3 inches across, versus 1 and 2 inches for picklers. This gives slicers a signature long, tubular shape that is perfect for cutting sandwich slices, spears, and chips. Picklers, on the other hand, take on a shorter, squatter, almost oval form factor, ideal for fitting neatly into jars.

Skin and Seeds

Pickling cucumbers stand out from their slicer cousins thanks to their bumpy, knobby, dark green skin covered in tiny spikes versus the smooth, polished exterior of slicers. Pickler skin is also slightly thicker, which helps it hold up to the brining process while maintaining that satisfying pickle crunch. Inside, picklers feature a central cavity crammed full of large, white seeds. Slicers have tiny, nearly undetectable edible seeds that complement (rather than compete) with the vegetable’s delicate flavor. The abundant seeds are necessary, though, for giving pickles their robust, tangy taste during fermentation.

Taste and Texture

When eaten raw, slicers offer a mild, sweet, grassy cucumber flavor with a delightfully crisp, watery crunch. Their thin skins do not require peeling, allowing the whole veggie’s refreshing qualities to shine through. Picklers, on the other hand, have rather bland white flesh surrounding a seedy core that brings a slightly bitter bite. The dense texture also lacks that signature wateriness prized in fresh-eating slicers. But while raw picklers may be lackluster, everything changes once they are brined and transformed into pickled products. Soaking in salty, spicy vinegars concentrates flavors for a sour, garlicky, robust eating experience, with plenty of spicy seeds sprinkled throughout, contributing taste, crunch, and visual appeal.

Best Applications

With their mild disposition, pretty appearance, and satisfying snap, slicers are obviously best suited for eating raw in salads, sides, snacks, and other chilled preparations. Their high water content makes them perfect thirst-quenching additions to summer picnic fare. Picklers, meanwhile, were bred expressly for processing into pickled goodies like dilly beans, relishes, pickled peppers, and all sorts of jarred or canned products. Their petite size lets processors and home cooks pack jars tight with cucumber chunks that hold up to months of storage immersed in briny broth. So while they may seem interchangeable at first glance, understanding whether a recipe calls for slicers versus picklers makes all the difference!

Growing Tips

When cultivating cucumbers, it is important to choose varieties suited specifically for your climate and intended use—fresh eating slicers versus pickling types. Both plants require full sun exposure in fertile, well-draining soil. Space seeds or seedlings 12–24 inches apart in rows or raised beds, providing trellises for the vining plants to climb up. This improves air circulation and prevents disease. Supply at least 1-2 inches of water weekly, and watch for common pests like squash bugs. Harvest slicers when fruits grow to the desired size but are still glossy green and firm. Allow picklers to achieve golf ball dimensions for peak flavor balance. Enjoy the slices immediately or store them in the fridge for up to 10 days. Pickling cukes will keep fresh for 4-5 days before brining or processing. With proper site selection and attentive care, both cucumber varieties can provide bountiful summer harvests.

When choosing between slicers and picklers, consider your intended use, as their size, texture, and taste vary significantly. Slicers’ thin skins, crisp flesh, and mild flavor are perfect for eating raw. Picklers’ petite size, bumpy skins, and abundant seeds make them ideal candidates for all sorts of pickled products. Let your appetite guide you; sandwiches and salads call for slicers, while pickles demand picklers. Selecting the best cuke for the job makes summer recipes even more refreshing!

Categorized in: