Homemade cheese that’s so easy to make, you’ll wonder why you ever bought it from the store! All you need is milk, lemon juice, and salt to create fresh, tasty cheese right in your own kitchen. Far simpler than you imagined, whipping up a batch takes minutes and requires no fancy equipment. Read on to learn the basics of crafting creamy, dreamy cheese that even the most novice cook can master!

Background on Fresh Cheese and Its Benefits

Fresh cheese is a creamy, soft cheese made from curdled milk without the molding or aging process used for hard cheeses like parmesan or cheddar. Popular fresh cheeses include soft spreadable varieties like ricotta, queso fresco, paneer, cottage cheese, cream cheese, and fromage blanc.

Types of Fresh Cheese

Fresh cheese refers to any soft, rindless cheese that is not aged or cured. Popular varieties like farmers cheese, paneer, queso fresco, cottage cheese, ricotta, and fromage blanc can range from moist and creamy to more crumbly in texture. They are typically made by curdling milk with an acid like lemon juice or vinegar and then draining off the whey.

Nutrition and Health Benefits

Besides being deliciously creamy and versatile, fresh cheeses offer a range of nutritional and health perks. They are packed with protein, calcium, vitamins A, D, and B12, along with a number of bone-strengthening minerals. As fermented foods, fresh cheeses can also boost healthy gut flora linked to improved digestion, immunity, mood, and even weight regulation. For those watching their weight, the combination of ample protein and calcium, coupled with calcium’s potential role in fat metabolism, can also aid weight and fat loss when substituted for higher-calorie ingredients. Lighter varieties, like part-skim ricotta and cottage cheese, are ideal diet swaps to still get a creamy fix.

Making Your Own Fresh Cheese

Ingredients and Equipment Needed

The beauty of homemade, fresh cheese is its simplicity. All you need is milk, lemon juice, salt, and a thermometer, if you have one. Optional flavorings can be added, like herbs, peppers, or spices. Equipment-wise, you just need a heavy-bottomed pot, slotted spoon, colander, cheesecloth, ladle, and an airtight container for storage.

Step-by-step Instructions 

Transforming milk into luscious cheese is surprisingly easy, thanks to a reaction between the milk proteins and acid from lemon juice. Just heat, curdle, drain, and salt—that’s all it takes!

Heating and Curdling the Milk

Start by pouring your milk into a heavy-bottomed pot and warming it slowly over medium-low heat. Warm to 190°F if using a thermometer, or just until steam starts rising and small bubbles appear around the edge. Stirring often, pour in your lemon juice a little at a time. Watch as the acid causes the milk to curdle, separating into clumpy white curds and transparent whey. Remove from heat once fully curdled.

Draining the Curds

Line a colander with cheesecloth and ladle in the warm curds, letting the whey strain through. Gather the corners of the cloth and twist over the top, squeezing out excess moisture. Open and scrape down the sides every few minutes to help the whey drain. After 10–15 minutes, open the bundle and sprinkle the desired amount of salt over the curds, mixing gently to incorporate.

Salting and Shaping

Add any additional mix-ins, like herbs, now if you are using them. Form the salted cheese into balls or logs, or simply leave it loose. Store it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to a week. Enjoy your fresh homemade cheese in salads, snacks, charcuterie spreads, and endless recipes for up to a week.

Tips for Adjusting Fresh Cheese Recipe

One of the great things about DIY fresh cheese is how versatile and customizable it can be. Whether you prefer a thicker Greek yogurt-style cheese or a light and spreadable fromage blanc, there are easy ways to modify texture, flavor, and ingredients to suit your tastes.

Texture Modifications

The texture of fresh cheeses comes down to moisture content. For a thicker, more scoopable cheese, drain the curds for a shorter time before salting to retain more moisture. For a drier, crumbly cheese, extend the draining time to remove even more whey. You can also experiment with different milks; using cream, half and half, or milk with a higher fat content will make a richer, creamier set cheese.

Flavor Additions

Stir in different herbs, spices, garlic, pepper, or other flavorings to liven up your homemade cheese. Options like mixed herbs, chives, dill, jalapeños, or chipotle flakes are all delicious. For sweet flavors, a touch of honey, maple syrup, or fruit preserves swirled in is delightful. Get creative with mix-ins like olives, sun-dried tomatoes, or roasted red peppers too.

Types of Milk to Use

Nearly any type of milk can be turned into fresh cheese, so tailor the ingredients to your tastes. Lower-fat milks, like 2% or skim milk, produce a lighter, more spreadable texture. Cream, half and half, or whole milk creates an ultra-rich and creamy cheese similar to ricotta. Goat or sheep milk offers a wonderful tangy twist. Non-dairy milks also work with a little texture modification; just add a touch of nonfat milk powder or decrease lemon juice slightly in plant-based varieties.

Whipping up fresh, tasty cheese at home has never been simpler. With just three ingredients, a bit of hands-on time, and the versatility to customize flavors and textures to your liking, you can now skip store-bought and enjoy the satisfying delight of creating your own dreamy, creamy cheeses to enjoy in endless ways.

Categorized in: