Homemade castile soap is a versatile, all-natural way to gently cleanse your skin and hair. While the classic recipe calls for 100% olive oil, you can experiment with substitutions to create custom soaps that match your needs. Swapping out oils or adding natural colorants creates a nice, thick lather and rich, creamy texture. With a few simple tweaks, you can transform basic castile soap into specialized bars for shaving, laundry, dishes, and more. Read on to learn five easy substitutions for making luxurious homemade castile soap right in your kitchen.

The Best Oils for Homemade Castile Soap

Olive Oil

Olive oil is the base of traditional castile soap recipes, prized for its rich, moisturizing lather. The oleic acid in olive oil creates a mild, gentle soap that won’t strip skin and hair. While 100% olive oil soap has an excellent creamy texture, bars can take months to fully harden. For a nice,, thick homemade castile soap, try using at least 50–75% high-quality extra virgin olive oil.

Coconut Oil

Adding 15–30% coconut oil to olive oil soap makes a nice hard bar with fluffy lather. The lauric acid in coconut oil boosts cleansing power and creates large bubbles. But too much coconut oil can cause dryness. For the best balance of moisturization and lather, stay below 30% coconut oil. Refined coconut oil makes a whiter bar, while unrefined adds a tropical scent.

Alternative Vegetable Oils

For a harder, longer-lasting bar, avocado or palm oil can replace part of the olive oil. Sunflower, safflower, or rice bran oils add skin-nourishing fatty acids without becoming too soft. Hemp seed or grapeseed oil makes a harder bar that still conditions. But don’t use more than 30% of these very hard oils to retain creaminess. Always run new oils through a lye calculator before substituting to ensure a balanced recipe.

Using Butter Instead of Oils

Shea Butter

Raw, unrefined shea butter is a creamy plant-based fat that can substitute for up to 25% of oils in castile soap recipes. Shea butter’s high content of oleic and stearic acids makes it a hard bar with exceptional moisturizing qualities. Its vitamins A and E nourish and smooth skin, while allantoin soothes irritated skin. But too much shea butter prevents soap from lathering well. For best results, use 5–15% shea butter in place of olive, coconut, or palm oils.

Cocoa Butter

Like shea butter, cocoa butter harnesses skin-loving fatty acids to make a beautifully moisturizing soap. Its creamy texture and delicious natural chocolate aroma make it a delightful addition. Replace 10–20% of oils with cocoa butter for a hard, long-lasting bar that releases a rich, foamy lather. Since it can accelerate tracing, add a thinner trace. Cocoa butter works best alongside coconut and palm oils rather than olive oil alone.

Other Butter Options

For a creamy homemade castile soap, you can also substitute plant-based mango, avocado, or coffee butter for up to 20% of the oils. Or use 5–10% beeswax for a harder bar. But too much wax prevents lathering. For animal-based options, lard, tallow, or lanolin make a bubbly bar that conditions the skin. But keep substitutions under 25% to retain a moisturizing, castile-like soap.

Changing the Superfat Percentage

Higher Superfat for Creamier Soap

The superfat percentage refers to the amount of oils left unincorporated into soap after saponification. A higher superfat of 5-8% makes a creamier bar less prone to drying skin, while a lower 1-3% superfat makes a harder, longer-lasting soap.

Castile soap recipes typically use 5% superfat for a nice balance of lather and moisturization. Bumping up the superfat to 8% makes the soap more conditioning for delicate skin. Simply use an online lye calculator to adjust your olive and coconut oils to an 8% superfat rate. The higher oil content counteracts the drying effects of coconut oil for a smooth, creamy lather that retains moisture.

Lower Superfat for Harder Bars

If your homemade castile soap remains too soft, reducing the superfat to 3% creates a firmer bar that lathers well. Run your recipe through a soap calculator to lower the amount of olive and coconut oils to the desired superfat percentage. The extra lye reacts with more oils to harden the bar. But don’t go below 3%, or the soap may be excessively drying. For an extra-hard bar with creamy lather, try a 20% coconut oil recipe with 3% superfat.

Adding Natural Colorants and Scents

Clays and Powders for Color

Natural minerals like clays, charcoal, and mica powder beautifully color homemade castile soap without using artificial dyes. Clay adds soothing minerals to nourish the skin. Mix in up to 1 teaspoon per pound of oils before tracing for vibrant hues. Red Moroccan clay makes terra-cotta orange soap, French green clay for minty bars, or Australian yellow clay for sunny lemon tones. Activated charcoal gives an inky black color when added to traced soap in 1/2 teaspoon increments. Mica powder sparkles, so stir in 1/4 teaspoon for a pearlescent sheen.

Essential Oils for Fragrance

Essential oils not only scent soap with natural aromas; they also provide skin and mood benefits. Stir your desired oils into a light trace at 0.5–1 ounces total per pound of soap, depending on strength. Citrus like lemon, sweet orange, and grapefruit add a fresh, uplifting scent. Floral options like lavender, geranium, and ylang ylang soothe stress. Herbals, including rosemary, peppermint, and tea tree, boost clarity. Woodsy pine, cedar, and fir balsam ground and center. Stick to 3 oils total for balance, and use mild oils at up to 1 ounce for sensitive skin.

Herbs and Spices for Scent

You can infuse homemade castile soap with herbs like calendula, rose petals, or lavender buds for natural fragrance and skin care. Steep loose dried herbs in hot olive oil for 30 minutes, then strain before mixing lye. Or make a strong herbal tea to replace water in soap recipes. Gently stir in oats, poppy seeds, or almond meal at a trace for gentle exfoliation and a light, earthy aroma. Even spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and turmeric add warming scents and anti-inflammatory benefits when blended into castile soap bars.

Tweaking the Lye Concentration

Less Lye for Milder Soap

The amount of lye used in soapmaking determines the soap’s hardness and cleansing ability. Typical olive oil castile soap uses a lye concentration of around 27–30% to create a balanced bar. But you can make a thicker, creamier homemade castile soap by reducing the lye concentration to 25%.

Running your recipe through a lye calculator, lower the water amount until only 25% comes from the lye-water solution. Replace the leftover water weight with milk or herbal tea instead. The lower alkalinity makes a mellower soap that retains more moisturizing oils to condition the skin. Bars trace faster thanks to fewer free water molecules. And the higher oil content makes a nice, thick homemade castile soap base perfect for shaving or facial bars.

More Lye for Harder Bars

If your homemade castile soap remains sticky or never fully hardens, try increasing the lye concentration up to 33% instead. Simply enter your recipe in an online lye calculator and reduce the liquid added to the lye until it forms 33% of the total soap batch weight. This leaves less excess oil unreacted in the soap, allowing more complete saponification for harder bars.

But don’t increase the lye by over 35%, or it will become too drying. Check for “zap,” an overly alkaline feeling on your tongue, if tweaking lye concentration. For the best thick homemade castile soap, stay near the classic 30% lye concentration.

Troubleshooting Issues

Fixing Rancid Oils

If your homemade castile soap develops a stale, crayon-like scent, one or more oils have turned rancid. Prevent rancidity by storing oils properly and sticking to the superfat recommended by lye calculators. Rancid batches must be rebatched. Grate soap and melt in a crockpot with water, milk or fresh oils. Mix well, then pour into molds to solidify before use.

Preventing Separation

To prevent water pooling on top of solid homemade castile soap bars, be sure to fully incorporate water and lye until emulsified. Stick the blend to a thick trace for a stable emulsion. If using milks, freeze first or add sodium lactate. Salt water soaking is another option to draw excess liquid back into the bar over time.

Experimenting with different oils, butters, superfats, natural colorants, and lye concentrations lets you customize creamy homemade castile soap bars. Tweak basic recipes to create specialized soaps for shaving, laundry, bathing, or even dishes while retaining the gentle, moisturizing feel of classic olive oil castile soap.

Categorized in: