Clay makes for an incredibly versatile additive to handmade soap. Different clay types each have unique qualities to benefit soap, whether absorbing excess oils, cleansing pores, or exfoliating skin. Kaolin, rhassoul, bentonite, and Moroccan clays rate among the best for soap crafting. But with varied properties across clays, how do beginners pick the right one? This guide spotlights the top clay choices for soapmaking, explains the key traits soapmakers should evaluate when selecting clay, and provides helpful tips for working with these earthy ingredients to whip up homemade soaps. Read on to learn how to discern the perfect clay for your next soap creation.

The Best Clays for Soapmaking

When searching for a high-quality clay to incorporate into homemade soaps, four varieties stand out as top choices:

Kaolin Clay

Kaolin clay, also called China clay or white clay, offers a very gentle option. It has a mild pH level between 4-5, as close to neutral as clay can be. Known for being non-drying and non-irritating with fine particles, kaolin clay helps silk up the lather in soap recipes. It also lightly cleanses skin and balances oil production without stripping or over-drying. The white or slightly off-white hue works well for natural color palettes. With a smooth, creamy texture, soaps made with kaolin clay have an ultra-luxurious feel.

Bentonite Clay

Bentonite clay stems from volcanic ash sediment, giving it more minerals than other clays. It has stronger absorbent and cleansing properties, making it ideal for oily, acne-prone skin types. The tighter ionic charge of bentonite enables it to draw out impurities. This versatility also allows it to replace or supplement some of the oils in soap recipes. Bentonite clay comes in shades ranging from light gray to olive green based on its mineral content. Just be cautious with bentonite, as it can dry out skin if overused.

Rhassoul Clay

Mined from the Atlas Mountains of Morocco, rhassoul clay is prized for its rich mineral composition and incredible smoothing capacity for skin and hair. It shares similarities with bentonite, touting strong cleansing, absorption, and even some natural lathering ability. But rhassoul clay is milder thanks to its smaller particle size and balanced pH of around 5-7. The creamy brown clay with reddish tones has a rich botanical scent. It makes a luxurious addition to olive oil-based soaps.

Moroccan Clays

Beyond rhassoul, other treasured Moroccan clays, like red, yellow, and green varieties, offer artisanal soapmakers dynamic options. Though less common than the previous clays discussed, these vividly hued Moroccan clays bring visual appeal along with purifying and exfoliating perks.

Red Moroccan clay carries a distinct earthy scent, a deeper blood red color, and a slightly more gritty texture. It shares similarities with bentonite for absorbing oil and cleansing pores but is less drying. Yellow Moroccan clay makes for a brighter pop of pigment. It too exfoliates skin, though more gently than the red variety. Finally, green Moroccan clay lands between red and yellow in properties. It falls on the more emollient, protective side, so it is best for dry skin.

Key Properties to Consider When Choosing a Clay

With the wide range of clay options for soapmaking, deciding between them depends on evaluating some core characteristics:

Absorbency and Cleaning Ability

The foremost role of clay in soap is to absorb excess oils and cleanse the skin. The more absorbent a clay, the more it soaks up oils. Bentonite, rhassoul, and Moroccan clays excel here. Too much absorption, though, can strip away healthy skin oils and moisture. For mild cleansing without over-drying, kaolin and other gentler clays work well. Test different clay amounts when formulating to strike the right balance.

Color and Scent

Clays also influence the color, and sometimes scent, of soaps. White kaolin lightens, while Moroccan varieties lend vivid reds, greens, and yellows. Bentonite ranges from gray to green. Rhassoul is light brown. Whether you aim for a bright, pigmented soap or a neutral, elegant bar, color plays a role. Also consider any inherent scents in clays, like the earthiness of red Morocco. Make sure the added fragrances blend well rather than compete.

Plasticity and Smoothness

A clay’s plasticity determines how easily it molds, while particle size affects smoothness. Plastic, smooth clays lend a silky texture to soaps for a luxurious user experience. They help soap batter emulsify too. Kaolin and French green clays have renowned smoothness. However, more plastic clays may counter the hardness of palm oil or the thickening properties of sodium lactate. Finding the right consistency takes trial and error.

Cation Exchange Capacity

This refers to the ionic charge in clay from metals and salts. Negative charges attract positive oils for better absorption. Bentonite has excellent cation exchange thanks to its origin in volcanic ash rather than sedimentary deposits. High exchange also supports substituting clay for some oils in recipes. However, too strong an attraction risks overdrying. As with other metrics, balance stands paramount when formulating.

Shelf Life

Finally, evaluate clays for how stable they are over time. Are they prone to harboring mold or bacteria? Do they maintain integrity well through saponification? Shelf life depends partly on clay purity. Kaolin, for instance, offers excellent stability, while lower-grade bentonite may deteriorate faster. Storage methods also impact longevity, with clays lasting longer in cold, dark places. Test small batches first when trying new clays to ensure they withstand soapmaking conditions over months of curing and years of use.

Tips for Working with Clay in Soapmaking

Successfully using clay in soaps requires following some best practices:

Measuring and Mixing

Carefully measure clay amounts, erring lower until familiar with the end results. Ensure tools and containers are completely dry first. Mix clays thoroughly with other dry ingredients, like botanicals, before adding them to oils and lye water. Prevent clumping by sifting powders first, too. Stir gently to evenly incorporate clay, being cautious not to introduce excess air bubbles. Consider substituting up to one teaspoon of clay per pound of oil as a general rule of thumb when formulating.

Avoiding Lumps

Hydrate clays fully in water for several hours before using them to allow absorption and swelling. Soak larger clay pieces, then strain the residual liquid. Adding clay powder directly to thick oils risks clumping. If clay lumps during soaping, using an immersion blender can smooth out the batter. Move the blender around continually on a low setting to gently reincorporate.

Drying and Curing

Because clays absorb moisture, allow adequate drying time for clay-heavy soaps. Rotation drying assists here. Fully cure soaps for 3–6 weeks as clay particles continue interacting during saponification. Interestingly, some clays increase hardness during curing, while others maintain moldability longer. Test cured soap qualities over time when trying new clay types.

Observing these simple but important guidelines when mixing, coloring, pouring, and curing soaps with clay promises excellent, lump-free results.

When crafted well, clay makes for an indulgent, skin-enhancing addition to handmade soaps. From versatile kaolin to exotic Moroccan varieties, understanding each clay’s unique properties allows soapmakers to select the perfect ingredient for customized recipes. Let your imagination run wild with the many earthen options to create boutique-quality beauty bars.

Categorized in: